Zakharova, Anna V. Regional Interpretation of Constantinopolitan Models in Byzantine 11th-Century Architecture

Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://dx.doi.org/10.18688/aa2212-01-03
Title Regional Interpretation of Constantinopolitan Models in Byzantine 11th-Century Architecture
Author email zakharova@inbox.ru
About author Zakharova, Anna V. — Ph. D., associate professor. Lomonosov Moscow State University, Leninskie Gory, 1, 119991 Moscow, Russian Federation; Senior researcher. State Institute for Art Studies, Kozitsky per., 5, 125009, Moscow, Russian Federation. ORCID: 0000-0003-3764-171X
In the section Byzantine and Eastern Christian Art DOI10.18688/aa2212-01-03
Year 2022 Volume 12 Pages 52–76
Type of article RAR Index UDK 72.033 Index BBK 85.113 (4)
Abstract

The paper is dedicated to the process of adaptation of metropolitan trends in the architecture of Byzantine provinces in the 11th century. The author analyzes buildings in Macedonia, Attica, and Crete. These examples show how the main church type of this period was interpreted in different regions. The author discusses the particularities in the planning, style and technique, different versions of combining the metropolitan typology with older regional traditions, and modifications that depended on certain local conditions, models, or liturgical requirements. Thus, in the late 10th century a specific modification of inscribed cross church was created on Mount Athos, with two lateral apses that probably appeared in response to particular liturgical needs. It is likely that another addition to the Athonite type, the two-storey twin-domed narthex, also originated on Mount Athos as a replication of the venerated model (the Great Lavra katholikon) and/or in connection with housing the monastic libraries inside the churches. In the early 11th century other churches appeared reflecting these experiments with the basic Constantinopolitan type, representing its original and creative interpretations: the Church of the Holy Apostles in Athens and Panagia Chalkeon in Thessaloniki. Yet such examples remain unique. In Crete, in the first half of the 11th century, another version of the inscribed cross type emerges exemplified in the Churches of Zoodochos Pigi at Alikianou and St. Demetrius at Agios Demetrios near Rethymnon. These monuments have transitional character and combine the main features of the metropolitan type with older local peculiarities, such as the cross-shaped ground plan and niches in the eastern walls of the lateral cross-arms. The replication of these local traits was probably instigated by the donor, St. John Xenos, and relied on his earlier building, the katholikon of Myriokephala monastery (early 11th century). Later this local traits disappear and more standard versions of the inscribed cross churches spread in Crete.
Keywords
Reference Zakharova, Anna V. Regional Interpretation of Constantinopolitan Models in Byzantine 11th-Century Architecture. Actual Problems of Theory and History of Art: Collection of articles. Vol. 12. Eds A. V. Zakharova, S. V. Maltseva, E. Iu. Staniukovich-Denisova. — St. Petersburg: St. Petersburg Univ. Press, 2022, pp. 52–76. ISSN 2312-2129. http://dx.doi.org/10.18688/aa2212-01-03
Publication Article language russian
Bibliography
  • Adrianakis M. St John the Hermit and the Monastery of Gdernetou. Pepragmena tou E΄ Diethnous Kritologikou Synedriou, Agios Nikolaos, 25 Septemvriou – 1 Oktovriou 1981 (Proceedings of the 5th International Cretological Conference, Agios Nikolaos, September 25 – October 1, 1981), vol. 2. Iraklio, Etairia Kritikon Istorikon Meleton Publ., 1980, pp. 14–53 (in Greek).
  • Adrianakis M. New Data and Opinions on Monumental Art of Crete during the Second Byzantine Period. Pepragmena tou St΄ Diethnous Kritologikou Synedriou (Khania, 24–30 Avgoustou 1986) (Proceedings of the 6th International Cretological Conference, Chania 24–30 August, 1986), vol. 2. Chania, Philologikos Sillogos Khanion “O Khrisostomos” Publ., 1991, pp. 9–34 (in Greek).
  • Andrianakis M. Saint John Xenos and His Cult. Hadjitryfonos E. (ed.). Routes of Faith in the Medieval Mediterranean. History, Monuments, People, Pilgrimage Perspectives. Proceedings of an International Symposium. Thessalonike, European Centre of Byzantine and Post-Byzantine Monuments Publ., 2008, pp. 256–268.
  • Adrianakis M. Monumental Architecture of Crete during the Second Byzantine period. Pepragmena tou 10 Diethnous Kritologikou Synedriou, Agios Nikolaos, 25 Septemvriou – 1 Oktovriou 1981. Chania, Philologikos Sillogos Khanion “O Khrisostomos” Publ., 2011, pp. 309–361 (in Greek).
  • Antourakis G. Ai monai Miriokephalon kai Roustikon meta ton parekklision afton (The Monasteries of Myriokefla and Roustikon with Their Chapels), Ph. D. Dissertation. Athens, 1977.
  • Bakalova E. (ed.). The Ossuary of the Bachkovo Monastery. Plovdiv, Pygmalion Publ., 2003. 183 p.
  • Bouras Ch. Middle Byzantine Domed Cruciform Churches on the Greek Islands. Zograf, 1998/1999, no. 27, pp. 7–16.
  • Bouras Ch. Byzantine and Post-Byzantine Architecture in Greece. Athens, Melissa Publ., 2006. 312 p.
  • Bouras Ch. I arkhitektoniki tis monis tou Osiou Louka (The Architecture of Hosios Loukas Monastery). Athens, Melissa Publ., 2015. 154 p. (in Greek).
  • Bouras Ch. Byzantine Athens, 10th–12th Centuries. Athens, Routledge Publ., 2017. 336 p.
  • Bouras Ch. The Architecture of the Church of the Panaghia Mouchliotissa in Constantinople. Deltion of Christian Archaeological Society, 2005, vol. 26, pp. 35–50 (in Greek).
  • Ćurčić S. The Twin-Domed Narthex in Paleologan Arсhitecture. Recueil des travaux de l’institut d’études byzantines, 1971, vol. 13 , pp. 333–344.
  • Ćurčić S. Architectural Significance of Subsidiary Chapels in Middle Byzantine Churches. Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians, 1977, vol. 36, pp. 94–110.
  • Ćurčić S. Architecture in the Balkans from Diocletian to Süleyman the Magnificent (ca. 300 – ca. 1550). London; New Haven, Yale University Press Publ., 2010. 913 p.
  • Frantz A. The Church of the Holy Apostles at Athens. Princeton N.J., American School of Classical Studies at Athens Publ., 1971. 57 p.
  • Kappas M. G. I epharmogi tou stavroeidous engegrammenou sti mesi kai tin ysteri vyzantini periodo. To paradigma tou aplou tetrakioniou / tetrastilou (The Adaptation of the Inscribed Cross Church Type in the Middle and Late Byzantine Period. The Example of the Simple Four Column / Four Piers Type), Ph. D. Dissertation. Thessaloniki, 2009 (in Greek).
  • Kappas M. The Architectural Idiom of Thessaloniki during the Middle and Late Byzantine Periods: Similarities and Differences from Constantinople. Ivanov S.; Vinogradov A. (eds.). Byzantion and Byzantium: The Provincialism of the Center and the Centrality of the Provinces. St. Petersburg, Aleteia Publ., 2020, pp. 128–173 (in Russian).
  • Kappas M.; Mamaloukos S. The Church of St. Constantine on Lake Apollonia, Bithynia, Revisited. Deltion of Christian Archaeological Society, 2017, vol. 38, pp. 87–103.
  • Komech A. I. (ed.). History of Russian Art. Vol. 1. Art of Kievan Rus. From the 9th to the First Quarter of the 12th Century. Moscow, State Institute for Art Studies Publ., 2007. 664 p. (in Russian).
  • Lassithiotakis K. Churches of Western Crete. The Province of Sphakia. Kritika khronika (Annals of Crete), 1971, vol. 23, pp. 95–177 (in Greek).
  • Lilie R.-J.; Ludwig C.; Zielke B.; Pratsch Th. Ioannes Xenos: Ioánnis. Prosopographie der mittelbyzantinischen Zeit Online. Berlin, Boston, De Gruyter Publ., 2013. Available at: https://www.degruyter.com/database/PMBZ/entry/PMBZ25263/html (accessed 10 August 2022) (in German).
  • Mamaloukos S. The Katholikon of Vatopedi Monastery. History and Architecture, Ph. D. Dissertation. Athens, 2001 (in Greek).
  • Mamaloukos S. Treatment of the Facades with Inscribed and Painted Architectural Forms and Decorative Features in Mid-Byzantine Architecture. Architecture of Byzantium and Kievan Rus from the 9th to the 12th centuries. Materials of the International Seminar, November 17–21, 2009. St. Petersburg, The State Hermitage Publ., 2010, pp. 74–88.
  • Mamaloukos S. A Contribution to the Study of the “Athonite” Church Type of Byzantine Architecture. Zograf, 2011, no. 35, pp. 39–50.
  • Mamaloukos S. Notes on Athonite Byzantine Church Architecture. International Symposium in Honour of Emeritus Professor George Velenis, Thessaloniki, Amphitheatre of Ancient Agora, 4–7 October 2017, Proceedings. Athens, Ministry of Culture and Sports Publ., 2021, pp. 611–644 (in Greek).
  • Marinis V. The Monastery tou Libos. Architecture, Sculpture, and Liturgical Planning in Middle and Late Byzantine Constantinople, Ph. D. Dissertation. University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2005.
  • Marinis V. Architecture and Ritual in the Churches of Constantinople, Ninth to Fifteenth Centuries. New York, Cambridge University Press Publ., 2014. 262 р.
  • Megaw A. H. S. The Original Form of the Theotokos Church of Constantine Lips. Dumbarton Oaks Papers, 1964, vol. 18, pp. 279–298.
  • Messis V. Athonite Type Churches, Ph. D. Dissertation. Thessaloniki, 2010 (in Greek).
  • Miljković-Pepek P. Veljusa. Le monastère de la Vierge de Pitié au village près de Strumica. Skopje, Faculté des sciences philosophico-historiques de l’Université Cyrille et Methode – Skopje, 1981. 320 p. (in Macedonian).
  • Millet G. L’école grecque dans l’architecture byzantine. Paris, Leroux Publ., 1916. 328 p. (in French).
  • Moutsopoulos N. C. Peristera. Agglomeration montagneuse de Hortiati et l’église de Saint André. Thessalonique, s.e., 1986. 240 p. (in Greek).
  • Mutsopulos N. Harmonische Bauschnitte in der Kirchen vom Typ kreuzförmigen Innenbaus im griechischen Kernland. Byzantinische Zeitschrift, 1962, vol. 55, pp. 274–291 (in German).
  • Mylonas P. Le plan initial du catholicon de la Grande-Lavra au Mont Athos et la genèse du type du catholicon athonite. Cahiers archéologiques, 1984, vol. 32, pp. 39–112 (in French).
  • Mylonas P. Notice sur le katholikon d’Iviron. Actes d’Iviron, I. Des origines au milieu du XIe siècle. Paris, Lethielleux Publ., 1985, pp. 64–68 (in French).
  • Orlandos A.K. Two Byzantine Monuments of Western Crete. Arkhion ton Byzantinon mnimeion tis Ellados, 1955–1956, vol. 10, pp. 126–205 (in Greek).
  • Ousterhout R. Some Notes on the Construction of Christos ho Pantepoptes (Eski Imaret Camii) in Istanbul. Deltion of Christian Archaeological Society, 1991–1992, vol. 16, pp. 47–56.
  • Ousterhout R. Master Builders of Byzantium. Princeton, N.J., Princeton University Press Publ., 1999. 320 p.
  • Ousterhout R. A Byzantine Settlement in Cappadocia. Washington D.C., Dumbarton Oaks Research Library and Collection Publ., 2005. 474 p.
  • Ousterhout R. Eastern Medieval Architecture. The Building Traditions of Byzantium and Neighboring Lands. New York, Oxford University Press Publ., 2019. 816 p.
  • Paissidou M. The Сhurch “Panagia Chalkeon” in Thessaloniki: A Different Approach of a Monastic Institution and Its Founder. Siris. Studi e ricerche della Scuola di specializzazione in beni archeologici di Matera, 2015, vol. 15, pp. 121–133.
  • Papagopoulos G. Restoration Works at the Church of the Dormition of the Virgin in Kyrianna, Rethymnon. Archaeological Work in Crete. Proceedings of the 1st Meeting, Rethymnon, 28–30 November 2008, vol. 1. Rethymnon, Faculty of Philosophy of the University of Crete Publ., 2010, pp. 568–577 (in Greek).
  • Richardson J.O. The Byzantine Element in the Architecture and Architectural Sculpture of Venice, 1063–1140, Ph. D. Dissertation. Ann Arbor, 1988.
  • Savage M. Dome ‘Typology’ in Byzantine Constantinople? Architecture of Byzantium and Kievan Rus from the 9th to the 12th centuries. Materials of the International Seminar, November 17–21, 2009. St. Petersburg, The State Hermitage Publ., 2010, pp. 132–147.
  • Schäfer H. Architekturhistorische Beziehungen zwischen Byzanz und der Kiever Rus im 10 und 11 Jahrhundert. Istanbuler Mitteilungen, 1973/1974, vol. 23/24, pp. 197–224 (in German).
  • Stanković N. At the Threshold of the Heavens: the Narthex and Adjacent Spaces in Middle Byzantine Churches of Mount Athos (10th–11th Centuries) — Architecture, Function, and Meaning, Ph. D. Dissertation. Princeton, 2017.
  • Stanković N. Tradition, Innovation and Individual Creation in Monastic Architecture: The Case of St Athanasius the Athonite and the Katholikon of His Great Lavra. Art of the Byzantine World. Individuality in Artistic Creativity. A Collection of Essays in Honour of Olga Popova. Moscow, State Institute for Art Studies Publ., 2021, pp. 532–545.
  • Striker C. L. The Myrelaion (Bodrum Camii) in Istanbul. Princeton, Princeton University Press Publ., 1981. 50 p.
  • Tantsis A. Galleries in Byzantine Church Architecture, Ph. D. Dissertation. Thessloniki, 2008.
  • Theis L. Flankenräume im mittelbyzantinischen Kirchenbau. Wiesbaden, Reichert Verlag Publ., 2005. 216 p. (in German).
  • Theocharopoulou E. Notes on Inscribed Cross Churches of Crete. Pepragmena tou H΄ Diethnous Kritologikou Synedriou, Iraklio, 1996 (Proceedings of the 8th International Cretological Conference, Iraklio, 1996), vol. 2/1. Irakleio, Etaireia Kritikon Istorikon Meleton Publ., 2000, pp. 251–266 (in Greek)
  • Theocharopoulou E. Symvoli sti meleti ton stavroeidon engegrammenon naon tis Kritis apo ton 10o mekhri ton 13o aiona (Contribution to the Study of Inscribed Cross Churches of Crete from the 10th to the 13th Century), Ph. D. Dissertation. Athens, 2000 (in Greek).
  • Tomadakis N. B. St. John Xenos and His Testament. Kritika chronika (Annals of Crete), 1948, vol. 2, pp. 47–72 (in Greek).
  • Vasilaki M.; Pyrrou N. Excavation and Restoration of the Church of Agios Demetrios at Agios Demetrios, Rethymnon. Karanastasi P.; Tzigounaki A.; Tsigonaki Chr. (eds.). Archaeological Work in Crete, 3. Proceedings of the 3rd Meeting, Rethymnon, 5–8 December 2013, vol. 2. Rethymno, Ekdoseis filosofikis sholis Panepistimiou Kritis Publ., 2015, pp. 353–364 (in Greek).
  • Velenis G. Approche esthétique de l’architecture byzantine de Thessalonique. Aphieroma sti mnimi tou Sotiri Kissa (Volume in Memory of Sotiris Kissas). Thessaloniki, University Studio Press Publ., 2001, pp. 1–25 (in Greek).
  • Vinogradov A. Monastery of the Virgin Mouchliotissa. Orthodox Encyclopedia, vol. 54. Moscow, Orthodox Encyclopedia Publ., 2019, pp. 376–378 (in Russian).
  • Vinogradov A. On the “Fluidity” of a Middle Byzantine Building Crew (on the Example of the Imperial Churches of the 1040s). Zakharova A.; Maltseva S.; Staniukovich-Denisova E. (eds.). Actual Problems of Theory and History of Art: Collection of Articles, vol. 9. Lomonosov Moscow State University; St. Petersburg, NP-Print Publ., 2019, pp. 275–285 DOI: 10.18688/aa199-2-25 (in Russian).
  • Vinogradov A. Athonite Church or Arabian Palace? Cross-in-square Triconch and the New Architectural Identity of the Empire. Ivanov S.; Vinogradov A. Byzantion and Byzantium: The Provincialism of the Center and the Centrality of the Provinces. St. Petersburg, Aleteia Publ., 2020, pp. 91–126 (in Russian).
  • Vinogradov A. Constantinopolitan Builders in the Early 10th Century South-West Anatolia (Mastaura and Islamköy)? Zakharova A.; Ovcharova O.; Oretskaia I. (eds.). Art of the Byzantine World. Individuality in Artistic Creativity. A Collection of Essays in Honour of Olga Popova. Moscow, State Institute for Art Studies Publ., 2021, pp. 40–49 (in Russian).
  • Vinogradov A. Ex oriente crux2. Early Evolution of Byzantine Inscribed Cross Type Churches in the Light of New Findings. Boytsov M.; Voskoboynikov O. (eds.). God, Rome, People in Medieval Europe. Moscow, Higher School of Economics Publ., 2021, pp. 14–42 (in Russian).
  • Vocotopoulos P. L. The Concealed Course Technique: Further Examples and Few Remarks. Jahrbuch der Österreichischen Byzantinistik, 1979, vol. 28, pp. 247–260.
  • Vocotopoulos P. L. The Role of Constantinopolitan Architecture during the Middle and the Late Byzantine Period. Jahrbuch der Österreichischen Byzantinistik, 1981, vol. 31/2, pp. 551–573.
  • Vocotopoulos P. L. The Byzantine Church at Olynthos. International Symposium on Byzantine Macedonia, 324–1430 AD. Thessaloniki, Society of Macedonian Studies Publ., 1995, pp. 45–56 (in Greek).
  • Vocotopoulos P. L. Church Architecture in Greece during the Middle Byzantine Period. Perceptions of Byzantium and its Neighbours (843–1261). New York, The Metropolitan Museum of Art; Yale University Press Publ., 2000, pp. 154–167.
  • Voyadjis S. The Katholikon of Nea Moni in Chios Unveiled. Jahrbuch der Österreichischen Byzantinistik, 2009, vol. 59, pp. 229–242.
  • Voyadjis S. The Katholikon of the Greatest Lavra Monastery in Mount Athos. History and Architecture. Athens, Kapon Publ., 2019. 271 p. (in Greek).
  • Xyngopoulos A. Evretirion ton mesaionikon mnimeion 1, Athinon. Evretirion ton mesaionikon mnimeion tis Ellados, vol. 1.2. Athens, Arkhaiologikon tmima tou Ypourgiou Paidias Publ., 1929, pp. 59–122 (in Greek).
  • Zakharova A. Once again on the Originality of the Byzantine Architecture of the 11th Century: The Church of Panagia Chalkeon in Thessaloniki. Deltion of Christian Archaeological Society, 2022, vol. 43, pp. 81–94.
  • Zakharova A. V. Chernigov and Venice. On the Problem of Synthesis of Romanesque and Byzantine Elements in the Architecture of the 11th–12th Centuries. Lazarevskie chteniia. Art of Byzantium, Old Rus, Western Europe. Proceedings of the conference in memory of V. N. Lazarev, vol. 7. Moscow, KDU Publ., 2022 (in print) (in Russian).
  • Zakharova A. V.; Kurysheva M. A. How the Manuscripts Were Stored in Byzantine Monasteries. Drevnerusskoe iskusstvo (Old Russian Art) (in print) (in Russian).
  • Zakharova A. V.; Maltseva S. V. Artistic Traditions and Church Ideology in the Art of Macedonia at the Time of the Foundation of the Archbishopric of Ohrid. Vizantiiskii vremennik, 2022, vol. 106, pp. 174–199. (in Russian).
  • Zuliani F. (ed.). Veneto Romanico (Patrimonio artistico Italiano). Milano, Jaca Book Publ., 2008. 351 p. (in Italian).