Mal’tseva, Svetlana V. Historiography of the Morava Architecture: Controversial Points of the Study

Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://dx.doi.org/10.18688/aa188-9-74
Title Historiography of the Morava Architecture: Controversial Points of the Study
Author email s.maltseva@spbu.ru
About author Mal’tseva, Svetlana Vladislavovna — Ph. D., head lecturer. Saint Petersburg State University, Universitetskaia nab., 7/9, 199034 St. Petersburg, Russian Federation; senior researcher. Research Institute of the Theory and History of Architecture and Town Planning (branch of the Central Institute for Research and Design of the Ministry of Construction of Russian Federation), Dushinskaia ul., 9, 111024 Moscow, Russian Federation.
In the section Publication and Study of Sources DOI10.18688/aa188-9-74
Year 2018 Volume 8 Pages 742–756
Type of article RAR Index UDK 7.033.12; 7.033.2…7 Index BBK 85.113
Abstract

Based on the historiographic material the article is addressed to the main problems in the study of the Serbian Morava architecture.

In the 19th century the first critical research of the Serbian architecture placed it between the East and the West, formed certain approaches, and indicated some of the key issues influencing the study of the monuments of the Morava region.

In the beginning of the 20th century the definition of the Morava architecture was given by G. Millet who puts it in the ending of the proposed by him periodization of the Serbian medieval architecture seen as the array of separate ‘schools’ divided chronologically and geographically. G. Millet identifies the monuments of the ‘Morava school’ relying on the typological and stylistic uniformity, as well as territorial separation. Their main typological feature is the triсonch plan, which exists in two basic versions: a single-nave church or a four-pillared cross-dome church with separately standing pillars. Millet’s view on the specifics and chronology of the ‘Morava School’ up to now continues to exist as the base view on the history of Serbian architecture. However, further findings and the studying of the monuments accumulated a number of issues which destroyed the harmony the original concept. The subsequent study of the Morava architecture once again raised the questions of the chronology of the monuments, their relationship to Byzantine and earlier Serbian traditions, as well as the extent and the nature of Western influences. Even the issue of the origin of such a bright typological feature as the triconch plan is still controversial.

At the moment, it became clear that as a definition of the last period of the Serbian medieval architecture, the term ‘Morava school’ is hardly unambiguous and applicable, because there is no clear stylistic unity among the monuments of that era and no information neither about the terms of their construction, nor the craftsmen involved in it. In our view, the topics of the content, specifics, and mechanisms of the formation and evolution of the Serbian Morava architecture as an integrated regional phenomenon are to be put into foreground of modern research.

 
Keywords
Reference Mal’tseva, Svetlana V. Historiography of the Morava Architecture: Controversial Points of the Study. Actual Problems of Theory and History of Art: Collection of articles. Vol. 8. Ed. S. V. Mal’tseva, E. Iu. Staniukovich-Denisova, A. V. Zakharova. — St. Petersburg: St. Petersburg Univ. Press, 2018, pp. 742–756. ISSN 2312-2129. http://dx.doi.org/10.18688/aa188-9-74
Publication Article language english
Bibliography
  • 1. Belov М. V. U istokov serbskoi natsional’noi ideologii: mekhanizmy formirovaniia i spetsifika razvitiia (konets XVIII — seredina 30-kh gg. XIX veka) At the Origins of the Serbian National Ideology: The Mechanisms of Formation and the Specifics of Development (the End of the 18th — the Middle of the 30s of the 19th Century). Saint Petersburg, Aleteiia Publ., 2007. 544 p. (in Russian).
  • 2. Bogdanović J. Regional Developments in Late Byzantine Architecture and the Question of ‘Building Schools’: An Overlooked Case of the Fourteenth-Century Churches from the Region of Skopje. Byzantinoslavica, 2011, vol. 69/1–2, pp. 219–266.
  • 3. Bogdanović S. Mihailo Valtrović and Draguti Milutinović as Researchers of Serbian Antiquities. Izlozi Srpskog učenog društva. Belgrade, 1978, pp. 29–36 (in Serbian).
  • 4. Bogdanović S. Franc Mertens and Serbian Medieval Architecture. Zbornik za likovne umetnosti (Proceedings of Fine Arts), no. 15. Novi Sad, 1979, pp. 207–226 (in Serbian).
  • 5. Boshkovich D. The Architecture of Serbia and Macedonia. Vseobschaia istoriia arkhitektury (The Universal History of Architecture), vol. 3. Leningrad; Moscow, Stroiizdat Publ., 1966. pp. 418–464 (in Russian).
  • 6. Bošković Đ. Gabrijel Mije and Serbian Medieval Monuments. Srpski književni glasnik (Serbian Literary Journal), 1935, no. 46–6, pp. 475–477 (in Serbian).
  • 7. Bošković Đ. Osnovi srednjevekovne arhitekture (Basics of Medieval Architecture). Belgrade, 1947. (in Serbian).
  • 8. Bošković Đ. On Our Architecture of the Middle Ages in the Moscow Publication “The Universal History of Architecture”, Starinar, 1968, no. 18, pp. 225–231 (in Serbian).
  • 9. Ćirković S.; Mihaljčić R. Enciklopedija srpske istoriografije (Encyclopedia of Serbian Historiography). Belgrade, Knowledge Publ., 1997. XV, 741 p. (in Serbian).
  • 10. Ćurčić S. Articulation of Church Facades during the First Half of the Fourteenth Century. Vizantijska umetnost početkom XIV veka. Naučni skup u Gračanici (Byzantine Art at the Beginning of the 14th Century. Scientific Conference in Gračanica). Belgrade, 1978, pp. 17–27.
  • 11. Ćurčić S. The Architectural Significance of the Hilandar Kafolikon. Fourth Annual Byzantine Studies Conference. Abstracts of Papers. Ann Harbour, University of Michigan Publ., 1978, pp. 14–15.
  • 12. Ćurčić S. Architecture in the Byzantine Sphere of Influence around the Middle of the Fourteenth Century. Dečani i vizantijska umetnost sredinnom XIV veka. Međunarodni naučni skup povodom 650 godina manastira Dečana. Septembar 1985 (Dechany and Byzantium Art of the Mid. 14th Century. Materials of the International Conference Dedicated to the 650th Anniversary of Dechany Monastery. September, 1985). Belrade, Jedinstvo Publ., 1989, pp. 55–68.
  • 13. Ćurčić S. Architecture in the Balkans from Diocletian to Suleyman the Magnificent (ca. 300 — ca. 1550). London; New Haven, Yale University Press Publ., 2010. 914 p.
  • 14. Deroko А. Monumentalna i dekorativna arhitektura u srednjevekovnoj Srbiji (Monumental and Decorative Architecture in Medieval Serbia). Belgrade, Turistička štampa Publ., 1985 (in Serbian).
  • 15. Đurić V. J. Church of St. Peter in Bogdašić and Its Frescoes. Zograf, 1985, vol. 16, pp. 31–36. (in Serbian).
  • 16. Forster L. Die Baukunst der Kirchen und Kloster im Orient: Allgemeine Bauzeitung 22. Wien, L. Forsters artistische Anstalt Publ., 1857. (in German).
  • 17. Jovanović М. Austrian Architect Ludwig Forster as a Writer on Byzantine and Serbian Churches. Saopštenja (Announcements), 1985, vol. 17, pp. 213–218.
  • 18. Kadijević А. Jedan vek traženja nacionalnog stila u srpskoj arhitekturi (sredina XIX — sredina XX veka) (A Century of Searching for a National Style in Serbian Architecture (mid 19th — mid 20th Century). Belgrade, Građevinska knjiga Publ., 1997. 387 p. (in Serbian).
  • 19. Kanitz F. Serbiens Byzantinische Monumente. Wien, Hof-& Staatsdruckerei Publ., 1862. 27 p. (in German).
  • 20. Kanitz F. Serbien. Historisch-ethnographische Reisestudien. Leipzig, H. Fries Publ., 1868. 744 p. (in German).
  • 21. Kanitz F. Das Konigreich Serbien und das Serbenvolk von der Romerzeit bis zur Gegenwart: Land und Bevolkerung. Leipzig, Bernhard Meyer Publ., 1909. 594 p. (in German).
  • 22. Kanitz F. Serbia: Zemlja i stanovništvo (Serbia: Land and Population). vol. 1–2. Belgrade, Srpska književna zadruga Publ., 1985 (in Serbian).
  • 23. Karadžić V. S. Geografičesko-statističesko opisanije Srbije (Geographical and Statistical Description of Serbia). Belgrade, 1826–1828 (in Serbian).
  • 24. Katanić N. Dekorativna kamena plastika Moravske škole (Decorative Stone Plastics of the Morava School). Belgrade, Prosveta Publ., 1988. 266 p. (in Serbian).
  • 25. Korać V. Les origines de ľecole de la Morava. Moravska škola i njeno doba: naučni skup u Resavi 1968 (Morava School and Its Age: Scientific Conference in Resava 1968). Belgrade, Filozofski fakultet, Odeljenje za istoriju umetnosti Publ., 1972, pp. 157–168 (in French).
  • 26. Korać V. Sources of Moravian Architecture. Između Vizantije i Zapada:Odabrane Studije o Arhitekturi (Between Byzantium and the West: Selected Studies on Architecture). Belgrade, Prosveta Publ., 1987, pp. 131–144 (in Serbian).
  • 27. Korać V. Monumental Architecture in Byzantium and in Serbia in the Last Century of Byzantium. Features of the Facade Decoration. Zbornik radova Vizantološkog instituta (Proceedings of the Byzantine Institute), 2006, no. 43, pp. 209–213 (in Serbian).
  • 28. Krautheimer R. Early Christian and Byzantine Architecture. 4th ed. (revised by R. Krautheimer and S. Ćurčić). New Haven, London, Yale University Press, The Pelican history of art Publ., 1986. 553 p.
  • 29. Magarasević Đ. Putovanje po Srbiji u 1827 godine (Travel to Serbia in 1827). Belgrade, Prosvets Publ., 1983. 321 p. (in Serbian).
  • 30. Maksimović J. Srpska srednjovekovna skulptura (The Serbian Mediaeval Sculpture). Novi Sad, Matica Srpska Publ., 1971. 188 p. (in Serbian).
  • 31. Maksimović Ј. Moravian Sculpture. Moravska škola i njeno doba: naučni skup u Resavi 1968 (Morava School and Its Age: Scientific Conference in Resava 1968). Belgrade, Filozofski fakultet, Odeljenje za istoriju umetnosti Publ., 1972, pp. 181–188 (in Serbian).
  • 32. Mal’tseva S. V. About Some Problems of Division into Periods of Serbian Medieval Architecture. A Term Is Moravian School. Iskusstvoznanie (Art Studies), 2012, no. 3–4, pp. 95–116 (in Russian).
  • 33. Mango C. Byzantine Architecture. New York, Harry N. Abrams Publ., 1976. 382 p. (in German).
  • 34. Medaković D. The First Trials of Antiquities in Serbia. Istraživači srpskih starina (Researchers of Serbian Antiquities). Belgrade, Prosveta Publ., 1985. С. 154–157 (in Serbian).
  • 35. Mertens F. Etwas uber Serbien. Berliner Kalender fur 1847. Jahrgang 21. Berlin, Karl Reimarus Publ., 1847 (in German).
  • 36. Mihaljčić R. Prince Lazar and the Restoration of the Serbian State. O knezu Lazaru: Naučni skup u Kruševcu 1971 (Prince Lazar: Scientific Conference in Kruševac 1971). Belgrade, Naučno delo Publ., 1975, pp. 1–11 (in Serbian).
  • 37. Mihaljčić R. Lazar Hrebeljanović: istorija, kult, predanje (Lazar Hrebeljanović: History, Cult, Tradition). Belgrade, Bigz Publ., 1989. 378 p. (in Serbian).
  • 38. Millet G. L’Ecole grecque dans l’architecture byzantine. Paris, Leroux Publ., 1916 (in French).
  • 39. Millet G. L’ancient art serbe. Les eglises. Paris, E. de Boccard Publ., 1919. 208 p. (in French).
  • 40. Milutinović D. Short Discussion at the Opening of the 5th Exhibition of Photographs of Architecture, Painting and Sculpture 14 May 1878. Glasnik Srpskog učenog društva, 1879, vol. 47, pp. 251–258 (in Serbian).
  • 41. Misković-Prelević L. Catalogue of Drawings of Mihailo Valtrović and Dragutin Milutinović at the Historical Museum of Serbia. Izlozi Srpskog učenog društva. Belgrade, 1978, pp. 123–125 (in Serbian).
  • 42. Nenadović S. M. Some questions on the Construction Techniques and Style of Portals in Medieval Serbian Architecture. Raška baština (Raška Heritage), 1980, vol. 2, pp. 43–69 (in Sebian).
  • 43. Novaković S. Vaskrs države srpske: političko-istorijska studija o prvom srpskom ustanku 1804–1813 (The Easter State of Serbia: Political-Historical Study on the First Serbian Uprising (1804–1813). Belgrade, 1954 (in Serbian).
  • 44. Petković V. Pregled crkvenih spomenika kroz povesnicu srpskog naroda (A Review of Church Monuments of the Serbian People). Belgrade, 1950 (in Serbian).
  • 45. Pirh О. D. Putovanje po Srbiji u godini 1829 (Travel to Serbia in 1829). Belgrade, Prosveta Publ., 1983. 321 p. (in Serbian).
  • 46. Pokryshkin P. P. Pravoslavnaia tserkovnaia arkhitektura XII‒XVIII stoletii v nyneshnem serbskom Korolevstve (Orthodox Church Architecture of the 12th‒16th Centuries in the Present Serbian Kingdom). St. Petersburg, Imperatorskaia Akademiia khudozhestv Publ., 1906. 76 p. (in Russian).
  • 47. Popović S.; Ćurčić S. Naupara — korpus sakralne arhitekture Srbije u kasnom Srednjem veku 1355–1459 (Naupara — the Corpus of Sacred Architecture of Serbia in the Late Middle Ages 1355–1459). Belgrade, 2000 (in Serbian).
  • 48. Radojćić S. Odabrani članci i studije 1933–1978 (Selected Articles and Studies 1933–1978). Belgrade; Novi Sad. Matice Srpska Publ., 1982. 346 p. (in Serbian).
  • 49. Radulović Е. A Group of Moravian Monuments without Side Conches. Kruševački zbornik, 1989, vol. 4, pp. 47–78. (in Serbian).
  • 50. Ristić V. Moravska arhitektura (The Morava Architecture). Kruševac, Narodni muzej Publ., 1996, 372 p. (in Serbian).
  • 51. Šafarik J. Izvjestije o putovanju po Serbiji 1846 godine (Reports on Traveling to Serbia in 1846). L. Durković-Jakšić; M. Ž. Nikolić (ed.). Valjevo, 1993 (in Serbian).
  • 52. Srejvović D.; Milоје М. Vasic, a Founder of Serbian Archeology. Starinar, 1984, vol. 35, pp. 25–32. (in Serbian).
  • 53. Starodubtsev Т. Srpsko zidno slikarstvo u zemljama Lazarevića i Brankovića (Serbian Wall Painting in the Lands of Lazarevic and Brankovic), book 1–2. Belgrade, Univerzitet u Beogradu, Filozofski fakultet Publ., 2016 (in Serbian).
  • 54. Stevanović А. Old Serbian Church Architecture and Its Significance. Srpski književni glasnik, 1903, vol. 9 (in Serbian).
  • 55. Stevović I. Architecture of the Moravian Serbia: A Local Construction School or the Epilogue of the Leading Streams of the Post-Byzantine Architecture. Zbornik radova Vizantološkog instituta (Proceedings of the Byzantine Institute), 2006, no. 43, pp. 231–241 (in Serbian).
  • 56. Stevović I. Kalenić. Bogorodičina crkva u arhitekturi pozdnovizantijskog sveta (Kalenić. The Church of Our Lady and Architecture of Late Byzantine World). Belgrade, Interprint Publ., 2006. 216 p. (in Serbian).
  • 57. Stričević Ć. Two Variants of the Church Plans of the Moravian Architectural School. Zbornik radova Vizantološkog instituta (Proceedings of the Byzantine Institute), 1955, vol. 3, pp. 213–219 (in Serbian).
  • 58. Tatić Ž. Holy Archangels of Kučevište. Tatić Ž. Tragom velike prošlosti: Svetogorska pisma i monografske studije staree srpske arhitekture (Tracing the Great Past: Sanctuary Letters and Monographic Studies of the Old Serbian Architecture). Belgrade, 1929, pp. 175–189 (in Serbian).
  • 59. Todić B. The Time of Raising and Painting in Ljubostinje. Saopštenja, 2007, vol. 39, pp. 101–115 (in Serbian).
  • 60. Todić B. Monastery Ubožac. Kosovsko-metohijski zbornik, 2013, vol. 5, pp. 67–88 (in Serbian).
  • 61. Todić B. When the Holy Archangels Were Built near Kučevište. PATRIMONIUM. MK Spisanie za kulturnoto nasledstvo spomenici, restavracija, muzei (PATRIMONIUM. MK List of Cultural Heritage Monuments, Restoration, Museums), 2013, no. 11, pp. 173–184 (in Serbian).
  • 62. Trkulja J. Aesthetics and Symbolism of Late Byzantine Church Facades, 1204–1453, Ph. D. dissertation. Princeton University, 2004.
  • 63. Valtrović М. A View on the Old Serbian Church Architecture. Glas SKA (Bulletin of Serbian Royal Academy), 1889, vol. 17, pp. 3–39 (in Serbian).
  • 64. Valtrović М. Kalenic. Starinar, 1907, vol. 1, part 2, pp. 33–43 (in Serbian).
  • 65. Vasić М. Žiča i Lazarica. Studije iz srpske umetnosti srednjeg veka (Žiča and Lazarica. Studies in Serbian Art of the Middle Ages). Belgrade, Izdavačka knjižarnica Gece Kona Publ., 1928. 256 p. (in Serbian).
  • 66. Vujić Ј. Joakima Vujića, slaveno-serpskog spisatelja Putešestvije po Serbiji vo kratce sopstvennom rukom njegovom spisano u Kragujevcu u Serbiji (By Joakim Vujic, a Serbian Writer, Travels in Serbia, Briefly Written with His Own Hand in Kragujevac, Serbia). Budim Grad, 1828 (in Serbian).
  • 67. Vulović B. Ravanica. Its Place and Contribution in the Sacred Architecture of Morava. Saopštenja, 1966, vol. 7. 215 p. (in Serbian).
  • 68. Vulović B. The Role of Hilandar and Serbian Tradition in the Formation of Moravian Style. Moravska škola i njeno doba: Naučni skup u Resavi 1968 (The Morava School and Its Time: Scientific Conference in Resava 1968). Belgrade, Naučno delo Publ., 1972, pp. 169–178 (in Serbian).
  • 69. Vulović B. Architecture of Ravanica. Manastir Ravanica: Spomenica o šestoj stogodišnjici (Ravanica Monastery: To the 600th Anniversary of the Jubilee). Belgrade, Prosveta Publ., 1997 (in Serbian).
  • 70. Waltrowits M. O Prodromos: Mitteilungen uber neue Forschungen auf dem Gebiete serbischer Kirchenbaukunst. Wien, Lehmann & Wentzel Publ., 1878. 23 p. (in German).